NATASHA MOOR Magic Black Eyeliner Pencil - Water-resistant & Long-wearing | Smooth Black Eyeliner Pencil With Water-Resistant, Long-Wearing

**Editorial Review of the Magic Black Eyeliner Pencil** The Magic Black Eyeliner Pencil by Natasha Moor has garnered a mix of reviews from customers, resulting in a generally lukewarm reception. On one hand, the eyeliner is praised for its smooth application and the pleasant coal black color that many find flattering. Users appreciate its ability to create a smokey eye effect and note that it does not cause irritation, easily coming off with standard makeup remover. However, the pencil is not without its drawbacks. A significant number of reviews highlight its lack of pigmentation, especially in comparison to similarly priced competitors like Nyx and LA Girl. While the pencil is lightweight and has a creamy texture that glides on the skin, many users find that it requires a heavy hand to achieve the desired opacity. Additionally, it is a traditional pencil that requires sharpening—something that some users feel is not satisfactory for a product in this price range, especially as it is smaller than other drugstore aligners. Longevity appears to be another sticking point, with several reviews indicating that it fades after a few hours of wear, particularly when worn on the waterline. A common sentiment reflects disappointment over its value, especially given that more affordable options provide better pigmentation and wear time. Overall, while the eyeliner has a few redeeming qualities, many customers feel that there are more effective and budget-friendly alternatives available. **